The Great Pizza Debate: New York Style vs Chicago Deep Dish
Abram Noreen
Views: 42472
Pizza is one of the most beloved foods in the world, and two styles reign supreme: New York style and Chicago deep dish. The debate over which is better has been going on for decades, with passionate arguments on both sides. In this article, we will evaluate the merits of each style and attempt to determine a winner.
Detailed Evaluation

New York style pizza is known for its thin, crispy crust and foldable slices. It is typically topped with a simple tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and various toppings of your choice. The crust is the star of the show in this style, with a perfect balance of chewiness and crunch. Many New Yorkers argue that this style is the true essence of pizza, capturing the spirit of the city.

On the other hand, Chicago deep dish pizza is known for its thick, buttery crust and deep layers of cheese and toppings. It is more like a pie than a traditional pizza, with a deep dish filled with ingredients. The crust is flaky and holds up well to the heaping toppings. Chicagoans are proud of their deep dish pizza, often citing it as the ultimate comfort food.

So, what sets these two styles apart? The main differences can be summed up in thickness, crust, and toppings. New York style pizza is thin and crispy, while Chicago deep dish is thick and hearty. The crust in New York style is chewy and foldable, while in Chicago, it is flaky and buttery. As for the toppings, both styles offer a wide range of options, but Chicago deep dish is known for its deep layers of deliciousness.

In terms of popularity, New York style pizza has the upper hand. It is found in pizza shops all over the world and is often considered the go-to choice for pizza lovers. However, Chicago deep dish has a dedicated following and is a must-try for anyone visiting the Windy City.

In conclusion, both New York style and Chicago deep dish pizzas have their unique qualities and are loved by many. The best style ultimately comes down to personal preference. New York style offers a thin and crispy crust with a wide range of toppings, while Chicago deep dish provides a thick and hearty pizza pie experience. Whichever style you prefer, there is no denying the deliciousness of a good pizza.

Expert Ratings: New York Style Pizza - 4.5/5, Chicago Deep Dish Pizza - 4/5

Advantage Elements
  • Thin and crispy crust

  • Wide range of toppings

Defect Considerations
  • Not as hearty as deep dish

  • Can be too greasy

Total Score of 5 Points
3.3
New York Style Pizza
4.9
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Conclusion
Both New York style and Chicago deep dish pizzas have their fans, but ultimately, it comes down to personal preference. New York style offers a thin and crispy crust with a wide range of toppings, while Chicago deep dish provides a thick and hearty pizza pie experience. Whichever style you choose, you can't go wrong with a delicious pizza.
Selected Stories
PizzaLover
"As a New Yorker, I may be biased, but nothing beats a slice of New York style pizza. The crust is perfectly crispy and the toppings are always fresh. It's the quintessential pizza experience."
ChicagoPizzaFan
"I'm all about that deep dish life. The layers of cheese and toppings are what dreams are made of. Chicago deep dish is the ultimate comfort food."
Editor's Suggestion
Try both styles and decide for yourself which one you prefer. Don't be afraid to experiment with different toppings and crust thickness. And most importantly, enjoy every bite!
Cited Sources
  • https://www.pizzahistorybook.com

  • https://www.chicagopizzamuseum.org

Copy successful
vote
Which style of pizza do you prefer?
New York Style Pizza
37%
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
63%
Abram Noreen
Views: 42472
Total Score of 5 Points
3.3
New York Style Pizza
4.9
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
vote
Which style of pizza do you prefer?
New York Style Pizza
37%
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
63%
You May Like